Maryland Divorce Lawyer Blog
With more and more Maryland couples coming to a marriage with substantial assets, those couples have property disposition issues at the time of divorce. For example, I am frequently asked what happens to the marital home that is titled as tenants by the entirety, but that one spouse contributed a substantial amount of non-marital money towards (for instance, one spouse sold a home that was acquired before the marriage and never lived in by the parties, and used those proceeds for part or all of the down payment on the marital home). Clients ask is this home then marital or non-marital, and can I get all of the non-marital money I back that I put into the home? The answer is it depends.
In accordance with Section 8-201 of the Family Law Article, Annotated Code of Maryland, “marital property includes any interest in real property held by the parties as tenants by the entirety unless the real property is excluded by valid agreement.” Therefore, even if non-martial funds are used to purchase the marital home, if it is titled as tenants by the entirety (T by E) both spouses are equal owners of the home and it is marital property. Under this scenario, Maryland case law precludes the court from employing a “source of funds” theory as it may with other types of marital property. However, the court may utilize Section 8-205 of the Family Law Article to “reimburse” a spouse by way of a monetary award. This is not an automatic refund to the contributing spouse and by current Maryland case law cannot be when non-marital funds are used to purchase a home titled as tenants by the entirety, but the court may use the monetary award to correct inequities in the way which martial property is titled.
A three-step analysis is to be used when determining a monetary award in a Maryland divorce proceeding: (1) the trial court must first determine whether each piece of property owned by the parties is marital or non-marital, (2) the court must then determine the value of all marital property, and (3) the court may then make a monetary award as an adjustment of the parties’ equities and rights in the marital property. Oftentimes the biggest dispute arises over whether property is marital or not and in some case, partial marital and partial non-marital. If the home is titled T by E it is marital property. However, I have had cases where the home was owned prior to marriage by one spouse, the deed was changed at some point during the marriage to reflect a T by E ownership interest, and the Court found it was partly marital and partly non-marital.
Once the court applies the three step analysis, it then needs to take into consideration a number of other factors. Specifically, Section 8-205 of the Family Law Article, states that the court shall determine the amount and the method of payment of a monetary award, after considering each of the following factors: (1) the contributions, monetary and non-monetary, of each party to the well-being of the family; (2) the value of all property interests of each party; (3) the economic circumstances of each party at the time the award is to be made; (4) the circumstances that contributed to the estrangement of the parties; (5) the duration of the marriage; (6) the age of each party; (7) the physical and mental condition of each party; (8) how and when specific marital property or interest in property was acquired, including the effort expended by each party in accumulating the marital property or the interest in property, or both; (9) the contribution by either party of property to the acquisition of real property held by the parties as tenants by the entirety; (10) any award of alimony and any award or other provision that the court has made with respect to family use personal property or the family home; and (11) any other factor that the court considers necessary or appropriate to consider in order to arrive at a fair and equitable monetary award or transfer of an interest in property, or both. What this means is that even if the court determines the home is marital, there is a non-marital monetary contribution by one spouse, a monetary award is still not automatic. While the court must apply and take into consideration the required factors, the Court has discretion when applying those factors as to whether or not a monetary award should in fact be granted.
Obtaining a monetary award on behalf of a spouse or attempting to prevent a spouse from obtaining a monetary award in Maryland takes an experienced family law/divorce attorney. Judges make these decisions on a case by case basis, so if your attorney does not know the process, the law and how to apply the law to your special set of circumstances, the repercussions could be extremely costly.
For more information, contact Monica Scherer, Esq. at 410-625-4740